I’m not sure I am ready to write about race but I do want to write today and race is all that is on my mind. I’m no expert. I know what I believe and I know what I will fight for but I’m working on the words because it seems like now they matter more than ever. And, of course, my words pale in comparison to those with melanin but I also know that what we as white people say right now matters greatly. I'm going to read and write and process because I believe it takes all of us to continue to fight for this change that tis so long in coming. I am hopeful for an evolution rather than a revolution . . . I have to find who said that the other day because it rings so true, but for now I'm reading I'm Still Here by Austin Channing Brown.
Austin writes “This is partly what makes the fragility of whiteness so damn dangerous. It ignores the personhood of people of color and instead makes the feelings of whiteness the most important thing. It happens in classes and workshops, board meetings and staff meetings, via email and social media, but it takes other forms, too. If Black people are dying in the street, we must consult with white feelings before naming the evils of police brutality. If white family members are being racists, we must take Grandpa’s feelings into account before we proclaim our objections to such speech. If an organization’s policies are discriminatory and harmful, that can only be corrected if we can ensure white people won’t feel bad about the change. White fragility protects whiteness and forces Black people to fend for themselves.”
I work in a field that you would think would get this right more than we get it wrong but we don’t. There have been numerous times in my career where I have been told that the people I supervise would rather work for a man, that I’m too controlling, have too many ideas, I’m too strong, I’m too whatever. There have been times when white women have professed their Christianity and then done things to me, to students, to others, that are far from what I would hold as a Christian ideal. I read Austin’s words and it is real-I feel it as a white woman. I feel the people that don’t want me to be an authority because I grew up poor, or because I have a different experience than they do, or I’m too loud or any number of things. It is a power dynamic and I see it in play, I see the nervousness of admitting you might be wrong. I see the desire for everyone to be the same. I experience these, mostly women, who want to preserve the status quo over doing what is good or right for children and not because they don’t want to do right by kids, but because they believe they know better; they believe they have the corner on the market on thinking and knowing. We tiptoe around asking for change, for demanding more and I’m a part of the establishment, I’m the white majority. If I can see it in my space, I can only imagine how much more pervasive it is for my black colleagues. It is hard to decide if it is just a power struggle or a race and gender struggle as well. But isn’t that the same thing. This idea that someone has to lose for another to win is the trouble I see.
We have to talk more, we have to be less fragile, for the love, and we sure as hell have to figure this out before we let one more generation of students graduate without being seen, heard from and supported in a way that they deserve. If we, as white educators, can’t figure it out, how can the rest of the country? We have known for decades that there is a school to prison pipeline, but what are we doing, actively doing to change that?
I’m not sure I’m getting it all right but I’m reading and listening and thinking and processing and writing and raising up the voices of those that I respect. Today I listened to Wes Moore and Cory Booker, I’m reading more from Austin and I’m processing out loud right here in my words. I’m also reading fiction and napping and spending time with a puppy and my children because a full life does this work every day and not just when it is convenient or easy. I have the privilege to engage when it feels like the right time for me but what if my life or that of my children was dependent on me doing this every day, do I have the stamina, the will, the drive. I hope yes but until I know I have to commit to it. It just takes a minute but I think the results will matter if we all combine our minutes.