The time we are living in is so divisive and scary. People are so willing to argue and fight and unwilling to see an alternate perspective. The "comments" section of anything is filled with horrible, uncensored, hateful rhetoric. I believe that it is because people don't have to face their enemy, their opinion, anything really. They can just comment and leave their hate spread across the world.
When did we stop being able to have a conversation with someone that we disagree with, when did it become unkind. I remember having conversations with my family and friends that didn't end with our complete agreement with the other person, we simply talked things through. If we don't agree then we have the opportunity to convince someone of our opinion. We could actually read an article and start a dialog. Or not stand. Or kneel. Or invite someone to talk. Where is the love? And where is the desire to connect with someone rather than to just share your opinion or comment.
What happened to, if you don't have something nice to say then don't say it at all? Why do we always have to be right? It is so unnerving.
Last year I was observing a 5th grade teacher and she was teaching a lesson with the desire to have the students have a conversation, but first they had to read to understand the content of what they would be talking about. They read one article. A non-fiction article. There were facts in the article and really nothing else and immediately they decided that they had an opinion about those facts. The teacher only asked them to tell her what they read and they jumped to what they thought about the facts. And they are 10. They didn't know or have experience with the topic. They just thought they knew more than the facts. The teacher and I made eye contact and she redirected but in that moment I would like to think that we both thought, "Holy Hell." Where does that come from? Where do you learn that you have all the answers? What is that?
I don't have any answers but I do know that it is scary when you are proved wrong or that when you are presented with information that changes your mind, your foundation can feel a little shaken. I get that, I understand that when something hits close to home, you can feel strongly and when you are feeling a lot it is hard to listen, BUT with everything? The news has decided that they will now report on FaceBook comments made on stories that they put up. That is not news.
I hear people saying that he need to go back to that feeling after 9/11. YES, yes we do. But that feeling was not just a feeling. We came together because we left our houses, we were out from behind our computers and we looked our neighbors in the eye and had conversations. When we were scared on our next flight, we reached out to those next to us and shared kind words. We didn't roll our eyes because they took up too much of the armrest and we didn't snapchat a nasty picture of them. We leaned in. So when I hear that people want to go back, I completely agree and it starts with each of us. It starts with engaging in conversation and asking questions of people. It means stop commenting to be right and take what you read and find someone to talk to about it. You don't have to agree and I kind of hope you won't because the words are powerful, the connection is meaningful.
As I was writing tonight, Cooper came in and said, "Mom, you know the people that believe in evolution and not God?" Out of the blue, out of nowhere. I just looked at him and said, "yes." He then went on to explain that for him they can both be right. I gave him another idea to think about regarding the bible and he hugged me and said, "Well, that's a deep thought for me to go consider." Yes, Cooper, yes. Consider something that is outside of what you were thinking and let's talk more about it.
That's all I'm suggesting. Consider rather than comment. Engage rather than deposit. Ask rather than judge. Just once. Try it. Just one time tomorrow, or next week, or once this month. Try listening and engaging. Inviting someone to coffee to discuss their opinion and convince them of yours without having to be right. Or, let yourself be changed. Good luck. And, if you have comments, I'll take the encouraging kind, thank you.
I learn something new almost every day, especially when I read and listen much more than I talk. Hard for this blabbermouth. I enjoy reading what you are pondering, Denise. You are a dandy writer! ~ Kris (I have to choose anonymous, so I'll sign KB and you'll know who it is.)
ReplyDeleteThank you, I love your stories so much--you should join me on this writing adventure!!!
Delete